Madam Speaker, I yield myself such time as I may consume.
Madam Speaker, just a week ago, in a historic election, the American people sent Congress a clear message: Bring down costs, end the forever wars, and stop the corruption that is lining the pockets of the White House insiders, billionaires, and corporate executives.
Families are struggling to pay for rent and groceries, while the President's reckless and illegal tariffs push their prices even higher. They are paying outrageous prices at the gas pump and on their utility bills while billionaires and the Trump family get richer and richer.
After hearing that resounding message from voters, what is the first bill that Republicans bring up? It is not a bill to lower costs, to end the war, to rein in AI, or to clean up corruption. It is a giveaway to banks, insurance companies, Wall Street investment firms, and unregulated retirement consultants.
Who pays for that giveaway? Teachers, nurses, and public servants, with their retirement savings, pay for it.
H.R. 1013 is widely opposed by the Americans it would most affect. The same people whose savings are at stake have told us where they stand. Teachers, nurses, public servants, and workers across the country do not want their retirement plans deregulated at the behest of Wall Street.
That is why this bill is opposed by groups such as: AARP; AFL-CIO; American Federation of Teachers; National Education Association; National Nurses United; Americans for Financial Reform; Service Employees International Union; Communications Workers of America; American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees; the UAW; North American Securities Administrators Association; Public Citizen; and the Consumer Federation of America.
This bill would strip safeguards from 403(b) plans, which are how teachers, nurses, and the staff of hospitals and charities save for retirement. These plans hold $1.6 trillion. This is not a small change.
Today, the mutual funds and variable annuities sold to these plans must be registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Registration gives a plan standard information on fees and risks so it can compare its options on behalf of the workers who have put their hard-earned money into it.
H.R. 1013 would let banks and insurance companies sell these plans two kinds of products without registering them with the SEC: collective investment trusts and insurance company separate accounts.
A school district choosing investments for its teachers' retirement plan would no longer get the standardized detailed information it gets today. That is the information it needs to make the best investment decision possible. Unlike a mutual fund, a collective investment trust has no independent board approving its fees.
H.R. 1013, however, would let banks and insurance companies sell two kinds of financial products without registering them with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Republicans call this parity with 401(k) plans. It is not.
Nearly every 401(k) plan is covered by the safeguards of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, or ERISA, which holds the people who run a plan to a fiduciary standard and requires fees to be disclosed to every participant. However, the vast majority of 403(b) plans are not covered by ERISA at all.
This bill lets the employer, who is often busy with their day-to-day job, hand the job of approving investments to “another person acting on behalf of the employer.” This bill does not require that that person be a fiduciary, that is to act in the best interests of the plan and to be registered with a Federal agency or even to be independent of the companies whose products they sell.
This bill also specifically exempts these products from U.S. securities laws, so a firm that sells only these products would not have to register with the SEC as a broker-dealer, and the SEC's best interest rule, which ensures that a financial intermediary is acting in the best interest of the retirement plan. That would not apply. As a result, unregulated retirement consultants will end up nickel-and-diming our teachers' retirement options and our nurses' retirement options.
Teachers have seen what hidden conflicts cost. For example, in 2020, a subsidiary of a major annuity company agreed to pay about $40 million to settle SEC charges because the SEC found that it failed to disclose to Florida teachers that its parent company had paid an outside group for 13 years to promote it. That case depended on the SEC's oversight of the firms that sell to teachers. This bill removes the SEC from protecting those very same teachers.
Collective investment trusts can also take risks that mutual funds cannot. Mutual funds face limits on the illiquid assets and on borrowing. Federal banking rules set no such limits for collective trusts. Some of these trusts are run by State-chartered trust companies with no Federal oversight at all.
Meanwhile, the Trump administration is moving to put risky private equity and private credit investments into workers' retirement plans. Collective investment trusts are a clear way to do just that.
I understand that there is a real desire to lower costs and increase competition for retirement plans, but this is not that approach. Democrats have offered a better path.
Ranking Member Waters offered an amendment that would let these plans use collective trusts, but it would require reforms and require trusts to benefit all investors by requiring them to publish their fees, disclose their holdings, explain how they conduct valuations and use leverage, and explain what they pay to middlemen who sell them. This approach would also hold State-chartered trust companies to the same standard. Republicans did not make that amendment in order.
I also offered an amendment that would only apply this bill to 403(b) plans that are also ERISA plans because those have added protections, which would ensure that there is still some Federal oversight and a fiduciary duty protecting those teachers and nurses.
Either amendment would change this bill into something that could become law. Again, we are not alone in these concerns. The teachers and nurses don't want their retirement plans being deregulated.
Last Tuesday, again, the American people rejected the Trump approach and this Republican Congress' efforts to put the people's interests last. They want Congress to change and to focus on their needs and not those of Wall Street.
Madam Speaker, I urge my colleagues to oppose H.R. 1013 unless we make the necessary changes to protect our teachers' and nurses' retirement plans. I reserve the balance of my time.
Madam Speaker, I yield myself such time as I may consume.
Madam Speaker, I have the greatest respect for the gentleman from Oklahoma, but I do need to take exception to the claim that collective investment trusts cost less than mutual funds on average and that allowing them would make it more affordable for teachers.
Collective investment trusts might have a lower price, but that is only because the safeguards that apply to those products have been stripped from them. They are gone. Products cost less, Madam Speaker, when you strip out the rules that protect the people who buy those products.
Think about our automobiles. Madam Speaker, you could sell a car more cheaply if you stripped out the seatbelts and the airbags. Adding the FDA to the process of drug approval probably makes it more expensive to produce those drugs. Those drugs might get cheaper if they didn't have to go through the FDA, but I don't think anyone really believes that that is how to make medicine more affordable, and it isn't how to make retirement affordable.
Proponents of this bill argue that collective investment trusts cost less than mutual funds on average, but on average isn't what a teacher pays. Collective investment trust fees are set by share class and negotiated plan by plan, so the biggest discount goes to the biggest plans. A small school district or a small community hospital insuring their nurses has the least bargaining power and would end up in the most expensive plan.
The fact is that as long as collective investment trusts do not disclose the same information as mutual funds, we don't really know whether they deliver on the promise to offer an inexpensive and equally safe investment option for teachers and nurses. If collective investment trusts are cheaper, then let them prove it, and that is by a side-by-side fee comparison with a similar mutual fund and the costs that those represent.
If they are as cheap as the proponents say, publishing their fees would only help them sell those products. The bill before us doesn't require these disclosures, doesn't require those listings, and doesn't require that production. Ranking Member Waters tried getting that level of disclosure in this bill, but she was unsuccessful.
Fees aren't the only cost. The assets held by collective investment trusts can also be risky and opaque. A collective investment trust has no independent board, and Federal banking rules put no limit on how much it can hold in hard-to-sell assets or how much it can borrow. A lower fee is no bargain if the fund is loaded with private assets that are hard to value, hard to sell, and nobody knows how these funds will perform when the going gets rough in the financial markets.
Teachers can already get low fees. Index mutual funds are available for a few hundredths of 1 percent a year. Teachers need better plans and clear information, not fewer protections.
Now, we are not against all collective investment trusts. Democrats propose letting 403(b) plans use them but with public disclosure of fees and holdings and disclosure of what the middlemen are being paid. No one is barred. They just have to disclose that information. That gets teachers the savings without the hidden risks, but Republicans would not include that provision in this bill, and our amendments were not allowed.
Mr. Speaker, I reserve the balance of my time.
Mr. Speaker, I yield myself such time as I may consume.
Mr. Speaker, I want to take a moment and talk about the people who are actually responsible for protecting these 403(b) plans. These are the cops on the beat.
In a collective bargaining framework under ERISA, the employers of these nurses and teachers, the schools and the hospitals, the people who are running those schools and hospitals and the unions that represent the employees whose plans are being protected, they have spoken out on this bill.
I am a former union president of the ironworkers union, so I know a lot of these folks personally. I have heard from them directly, as have many Members of Congress. They are not asking for this bill. They are not. They are in stiff opposition to this bill.
Believe me, their full-time job when their feet hit the ground in the morning is to protect these employees, nurses, and teachers. That is what we on this side want for 403(b) plans. We want what the teachers, nurses, labor unions, and employers that hold these 403(b) plans want.
Let me tell you what the AFL-CIO; the American Federation of Teachers; the National Education Association; National Nurses United, which came to the Hill; members and leadership of the Service Employees International Union, the SEIU; the Communications Workers of America; the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFSCME; and the United Auto Workers told me and Members of Congress about this bill.
They wrote that this bill “would open a new loophole enabling unregistered brokers to sell unregistered securities, such as collective investment trusts and variable annuities, to both ERISA and non-ERISA 403(b) plans and their participants. In practice, it would promote the sale of risky investment products by financial professionals who are not bound by the consumer protection standards that apply to registered brokers. Because non-ERISA 403(b) plans are widely used by public school teachers”--and nurses--“the bill would effectively strip away key safeguards for one of the most vulnerable groups of retirement savers.”
That says it all. The people holding these 403(b) plans do not want underregulated and risky products without the proper protections.
This begs the question: Who is actually asking for this bill? The loudest support comes from the industry that creates these products and those who sell them to these plans. In fact, the unions that represent our teachers and nurses actually oppose this bill.
Mr. Speaker, I reserve the balance of my time.
Mr. Speaker, I yield back the balance of my time.
Mr. Speaker, on that I demand the yeas and nays.