Energy (Executive Session)
November 16, 2026 · Spoken on the Senate floor · 3,572 words
Madam President, I rise today to talk about the energy affordability crisis in America and the false solutions that this permitting bill that we are going to be considering on the floor of the Senate will be presenting as real solutions when ultimately they are not.
Read the full statement
Madam President, I rise today to talk about the energy affordability crisis in America and the false solutions that this permitting bill that we are going to be considering on the floor of the Senate will be presenting as real solutions when ultimately they are not.
Families are struggling. Electricity bills are just too high. Data centers are gobbling up our land, gobbling up our electricity, gobbling up our water. They are pumping pollution into the air. Our water supplies are under major stress from contamination from forever chemicals known as PFAS and also from droughts and the Trump administration's attacks on protections for our wetlands and for our creeks.
And climate change is causing more and more harm to our communities with the super El Nino throwing weather, temperatures, and actual economies into chaos. Families want relief, and they want to have control over their communities and their lives.
This permitting bill is getting billed as the solution. Cut the costs and time it takes to get stuff through the Federal permitting process, which they promise will create trickle-down benefits for Americans in a more resilient energy grid, lower prices, and, hopefully, more clean energy that gets built instead of polluting fossil fuels.
And they are going to make it easier for developers of all stripes to build facilities of all kinds, from transmission wires carrying clean electricity to data centers doing computation for the latest artificial intelligence models.
We are going to make it easier to build petrochemical plants next to your kid's school, make it easier to build a pipeline through your apple orchards, make it easier to build a new copper mine on your fishing grounds.
Part of how this bill makes it easier to do all of those things is by making it harder for you, for your community, to do anything about it, now or forever.
Let's talk about data centers. We just had a big election on data centers. There are 17 data centers getting proposed right now for construction on our public lands, covering more than 17,000 acres of public lands across six Western States. Federal environmental laws like the National Environmental Protection Act help us understand how development will affect our air, our water, and species that could be endangered as well as other users of public lands.
But under this bill, if the Federal Government phones in the review process, say it doesn't consider how a data center could hurt the environment, communities wouldn't have any ability to stop the AI projects. At best, they could sue and get the courts to send the data center's permit back to the government for some edits, but they couldn't get the courts to throw out the permit entirely, no matter how many corners were cut or how much harm the project will do.
This bill eliminates the ability to vacate permits under the National Environmental Policy Act and the National Historic Preservation Act. If those laws are violated by a project, that project will still go forward. You are just out of luck if this bill becomes the law.
And under this bill, any data center that is less than two acres gets considered under a general permit, not a site-specific permit. This is a rubberstamp without any proper review.
It doesn't matter the specific conditions of a community. It doesn't matter whether kids go to school near the diesel generators or if the community is already parched for water. The Trump administration has already rolled out the red carpet for data centers in communities across our country. They are exempting Big Tech from our clean air laws. They are exempting Big Tech from our clean water laws.
Trump is giving Big Tech a big blank check for polluting. This bill would take many of Trump's Executive actions and write them into law, make them the law of our land, what he is doing. A new President wouldn't be able to bring sanity back. If the Democrats won in 2028, they wouldn't be able to bring the sanity back.
A better Executive branch wouldn't be able to restore community power because this would become the law. This wouldn't just be an Executive order, this would become the law, promulgated by the U.S. Senate.
We don't have to guess what data center companies will do to get their hands on our land and on our electricity. By the way, electricity rates, which are skyrocketing, they are already doing it right now.
Entergy is trying to seize foreign tracks of land in Louisiana through eminent domain so they can build transmission lines for Meta's, for Facebook's hyperscale data center. They are saying these land seizures are in the public interest. A data center developer in Pennsylvania is promising $10,000 to every family in town if they let them build a data center on 1,300 acres of their land. Families are still saying no, turning down $10,000 to protect their neighbors and environment from harm. That takes courage. That is happening all across our country.
That is what happened on election day. It was just 2 weeks ago. We just had a referendum on this issue. These communities are saying they cannot be bought, but if we pass this bill, Congress is going to ensure that those actions--that election that we just had--are not going to be heard on the floor of this body because this Congress is going to be selling them out.
The permitting bill sells out those communities for the promise of electricity bills that might go down by between $4 to $6 a month in 2040. Can I say that again? Your bills don't go down until 2040, and it is only by $4 a month. Is that really worth it?
We have pages out here right now who are 16 years old. They will be 30 years old before they see the benefit of this bill. That is not what this election was about. They deserve to get the response right now. That is what we should be considering on the floor.
Fifteen years from now, you might as well--$6 a month on your electricity bill right now. In exchange you lose your land, you lose your water, you lose your air, you lose your voice.
Data centers are at the forefront of Americans' minds when we talk about development because they are getting planned in front yards across our country.
We are projected to spend more than $10 trillion on data centers and AI infrastructure in the next 8 years. That is a higher percentage of our gross domestic product than we have spent on any kind of infrastructure in our history, including the expansion of our railroads in the late 1800s.
Let me say that again. We are projected as a country to spend more than $10 trillion on data centers and AI infrastructure over the next 8 years, which is higher than any other expenditure in the history of our Nation.
We should be debating that right now on the floor of the Senate. Our country is already reckoning with the projected impacts of that massive investment.
This bill doesn't just roll out the red carpet for data center developers, it puts them on a greased-up slide into towns across America. It shields them from any obligations to build and operate with public health or welfare in mind.
Now, it is true that this bill would make it possible to have data centers pay more of their fair share and prevent them from jacking up electricity costs for ratepayers. That is a policy that I strongly support.
This bill also includes language that would establish a data center community assistance program to give communities more resources to understand and address costs of development.
And, fundamentally, the ability to power the data centers that are getting built with renewables rather than behind the metered gas plants would be a far better policy for the climate than the alternative, and the ability to build new transmission is one component of that solution.
But those provisions only speak to part of the concerns that people are fairly raising as Big Tech and other big developers use their money and their political influence to run roughshod over their communities.
Nearly every Republican in the Senate has voted for this bill so far. Democrats are being asked to accept massive rollbacks of Federal environmental protections--the National Environmental Policy Act, the 1970 law which is the constitution for the environment in our country. It is the National Environmental Policy Act. The Clean Water Act would be rolled back. The Endangered Species Act would be rolled back.
There would be attacks on Tribal sovereignty in exchange for beneficial transmission and modest data center pricing policies.
With those rollbacks, States, Tribes, and communities are left without the levers they need to pause or halt an unwanted data center or gas plant. The administration could proceed with plans to build hyperscale data centers on our Federal public lands without the opportunity for meaningful environmental review or public intervention through the courts.
And the bill is still a boon for the dirty energy that Big Tech is doubling down on to power their data centers. The number of proposed gas plants to power data centers doubled to 189,000 megawatts in the first of this year alone. How much is 189,000 megawatts? Think of one big nuclear power plant. Then think of 189 nuclear power plants. That is from the first of this year alone.
Environmental law rollbacks in this bill would fast-track projects like the Portsmouth Powered Land Project, a 9,000-megawatt gas plant that would power a data center as the largest gas plant operating in the world and the country's largest source of power-sector pollution.
And it enables the construction of the gas pipelines that can get these data centers with the fossil fuel they demand.
We may see some benefits for clean energy from transmission build-out several years from now, but the devastation wreaked from massive natural gas build-out for data centers will be felt immediately.
Under this bill, Big Tech gets the bill cheaper, faster, and without consequence. And communities will be forced to witness the degradation of their land and suffer from more cancer-causing pollution in exchange for the promise of marginal savings.
In addition to the $5-a-month savings in 15 years, even modelers supporting this bill have found with modest to nonexistent climate and affordability benefits for our country. We are in a climate crisis right now. It is getting hotter and hotter and hotter. The storms are worse. The flooding is worse. The fires are more intense. It is happening all around the world. The United States is the leader.
This bill, what does it say? It says, well, in a best-case scenario, this bill would bring economywide emissions down by 3.8 percent by 2040 compared to business as usual.
In a worst-case scenario under this bill, it won't do anything at all. The bill won't do anything about climate change. It won't do anything to ensure that the climate forecasts that have been made will not just lead us continually on the glide path to a climate crisis-- when these pages are 30 years old, a climate crisis. This bill doesn't do anything for them in 2040.
An earlier Rhodium--a private company--Rhodium model of this bill found it could even increase economywide emissions by 1 percent-- increase them. That is not what young people want. Young people want solutions. Young people want solutions to the climate crisis. They want solutions to high-price energy. That is what they want.
And none of these models factor in the climate bomb represented by supercharged natural gas exports, buying into the lie--that climate action only matters within our own national borders.
If we start exporting--which we are already doing--massive amounts of natural gas off of our own soil and sending it overseas, that pollution that goes up is still making the planet warmer. It is being captured, and the planet will get warmer and warmer and warmer. That is not factored into this bill. That is not factored in.
I am a wholehearted backer of clean energy, and I believe that solar and wind and storage--especially offshore wind--are the keys to an independent, affordable, and reliable energy future.
The Trump administration has broken our energy system. Trump and his Cabinet have blocked 400 onshore wind projects and spent $4 billion to buy out and cancel 21,000 megawatts of offshore wind that would have brought a staggering amount of clean energy to our entire eastern seaboard. They have abused executive authorities to keep coal plants running, costing ratepayers more than $300 million in just 1 year.
Trump is attacking clean energy jobs and clean energy projects. So this permitting bill, will it bring clean energy back? Well, let's look. Let's look at the supporters of this bill and their models because their models, unfortunately, when you look at it, the answer is not really.
According to Rhodium, in the conservative case estimation, this bill would get an additional 17,000 megawatts of clean energy built over the next 15 years.
So for anyone that is listening, what is a megawatt? What is 1,000 megawatts? Last year, we deployed 50,000 megawatts of solar in the United States--50,000 new megawatts. This bill says you get 1,000 more per year. But the price? The National Environmental Policy Act, Clean Water Act, Endangered Species Act, and we don't get the tax breaks for wind and solar back that Trump took off the books last year. Those tax breaks for wind and solar were supercharging the deployment of clean energy in our Nation. We don't get them back. We don't get those tax breaks back as part of this deal.
And, honestly, if you think about it, that 1,000 megawatts a year-- because under current conditions, we are projected to build 70,000 megawatts of wind and solar in storage just next year. So this bill would represent a potential 1.4 percent increase in clean energy projects.
We make a lot of sacrifices to get that very small benefit, and the natural gas industry is just clinking their champagne glasses, just saying: This is great for us. We get permanent relief. We can build natural gas pipelines, polluting fossil fuel pipelines forever with no restrictions upon us. Wow, that is a good deal.
So here is the permitting bill pitch: 15 years from now, we might save you the cost of a cup of coffee a month in your electricity bills. We might increase clean energy growth by a little over 1 percent per year. We might see no change in our climate emissions. And that is what the bill's supporters are saying.
Those with concerns have a lot more to add. Tribes have been rightfully outraged by the attack on their sovereignty through the rollback of the National Historic Preservation Act. The National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers have called this bill “ . . . an assimilation-era tactic of telling us how and we can participate, what matters to our cultures, and [what] harms we [should] accept.”
I believe our Tribal leaders when they say this is not something that Tribal nations should have to bear. Yes, we might want transmission reform, but are we going to say to the Tribes all across our country: I am sorry. You have no rights anymore to stop them from coming through your sacred, historic Tribal areas?
People working every day in our States to safeguard our water and everyone who depends on it have called out the massive rollbacks in the Clean Water Act protections. Eight State environmental departments, including Massachusetts, have stated that the bill “significantly undermines State authority . . . crippling our ability--[crippling our ability]--to protect clean water in our States.”
That means less protection against PFAS, against flooding, against pollution, and other dirty water threats.
And the provisions that are meant to protect clean energy projects from Trump's blockade actually give him massive new powers to permit his favored fossil fuel projects and prevent future administrations from doing anything about it.
This creates more opportunity for Trump to push offshore drilling in California--offshore drilling for oil, for natural gas--in places that don't want it or mining in the Boundary Waters or major new fossil gas export terminals in the next 2 years.
And a future administration would not be able to do anything about it that in any way would affect “the construction of operation at normal capacity of a project that has gotten its permits,” meaning it is permitted. If the Democrats win the Presidency in 2028, that new President is not going to be able to affect this law. They are just going to continue to rumble right through areas of our country that otherwise would have had environmental protections.
At best, this creates a massive amount of legal uncertainty as to what the Federal Government can and can't do, as well as whether projects like offshore wind farms have any recourse against Trump's vindictiveness.
At worst, it gives Trump and his other administration officials unfettered power to shove projects down the throats of States and communities who do not want those projects.
Last week, you might have heard Trump was asked in a press conference: If this bill passes, are you going to allow for offshore wind to be constructed, which you have been blocking?
And he says: No, I won't. I don't like wind. I am not going to allow it to happen.
Well, that is the plan we have in Maine, in Massachusetts, in New Jersey, in New York, in Virginia, in Delaware, in Maryland. That is our plan: offshore wind. He is not saying we can do it. And the natural gas industry is saying: We will do it for you. We will build pipelines for fossil fuels into your States in order to produce the electricity which you need.
So if Trump is saying no in public, just last week, why don't we just take him at his word? Like Maya Angelou would say: When somebody tells you who they are, you should believe them.
He is telling us he will not allow it to happen. So where is the bargain for us that want a clean energy future? You know, otherwise, we are just going to have States that want to go clean energy just have Trump's vindictiveness there for the next 2 years with no guarantee, by the way, that there is ever going to be a Democratic President after 2028. You get no guarantees about the future.
This law, however, will be there as a guarantee. It will be something that the new President will have to live with. And, at worst, it is going to give Trump and all of the rest of his fossil fuel Cabinet-- make that fossil fuel cartel that is disguised as a Cabinet--the ability to shove projects down the throats of States and communities who don't want them, who don't want those fossil fuel projects.
So I believe we can find solutions to building clean power without taking power away from our Tribes, from our States, from our scientists. Tribes and our State clean water agencies aren't obstructions to progress; they are partners in progress. That is what we have constructed over the last 60 years in our country--a partnership with environmentalists and energy companies.
And we last year produced 50,000 new megawatts of solar; that wasn't on the scoreboard just 5 years before. Ten thousand new megawatts of wind; that wasn't on the scoreboard. Ten thousand new megawatts of battery storage technology; that wasn't on the scoreboard. That is part of the new plan we put in place that Trump last year had all the Republicans vote to kill.
Our progress will come from working with everyone to create those solutions--not by creating new enemies by establishing generational winners and losers with this permitting bill.
There are good provisions in this bill, but they are buried beneath unnecessary attacks on communities and dangerous new powers for President Trump and his agenda.
Don't permit Donald Trump to supercharge his crusade against our health and our bottom line. Don't permit data centers to get built under the cover of darkness. Don't permit this attack on Tribal sovereignty. Don't permit PFAS and pollution in our water. Don't permit this permitting bill to pass.
Americans demanded better from us when they voted for change 2 weeks ago. They deserve better. This bill is not a bill for the future. It is a bill negotiated under the existing political structure in this institution.
The American people voted for a new era, and that begins in January of 2027. We should be negotiating under those circumstances.
And we can produce legislation. We can make sure that everyone gets what they need. But we can't allow for legislation to pass which locks us into an era which does not dramatically increase the amount of clean energy, which does not reduce emissions, and which allows for these companies to continue to build their pipelines, filled with fossil fuels, into areas that otherwise would have had wind and solar and battery storage technology producing the energy those regions needed.
That is why I urge a “no” vote on this legislation. We can and we must do better.
I yield the floor.
Original page in the Congressional Record (172 Cong. Rec. S5676)