Mr. President, I am pleased to be able to follow my colleague from North Dakota in speaking about the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, BAAJA.
You used the word “balance” there, and I think that is important for us all to be concentrating on because, as you have noted, this is probably not a bill that the Senator from North Dakota would have written on his own, nor the bill that the Senator from Alaska would have written on her own or that the chairman of the Energy Committee or the chairman of EPW or the ranking members would have written on their own. But what we are doing here, folks, is we are legislating. My goodness, it is kind of good. It is kind of good.
So it feels good to be able to be on the floor and talk about where we are because I think this is the most substantive bipartisan agreement on permitting reform that we have reached since I have been serving here in the Senate now, and that really is a credit to its sponsors. I am going to come back to them shortly.
But I think the reason that BAAJA is the most important bill for us to enact before the end of the year is because of just the focus that we have been through with this recent campaign. The people in this country are focused on affordability. They want solid growth, and they want good government. And I think this is what this bill provides for us.
There is a lot of debate and dissension that goes on on this floor, but there is one thing that most Members of Congress would agree upon, and that is that our Federal permitting system is broken. It is really troubled. No matter what you want to do, where you plan to do it, your project is at a major disadvantage if you need to acquire a Federal permit. That is bottom line. That is because Federal permitting has evolved--or perhaps devolved--into something it was never meant to be. It is no longer a fair or a predictable process. It is this gauntlet, this series of gauntlets. It takes way too long. It costs way too much. And the Senator from North Dakota I think outlined that well--the cost of delay and what that means to us, to our communities, to our economies.
But also it leads to litigation inevitably, it seems, and that, too, adds to the cost. So even if your project survives all of this, your approvals can still be reopened and rejected on political grounds and sometimes years after the fact. When this happens, we don't need--we should not fool ourselves here. It is not like we are protecting the environment when we do this. What happens then is we end up outsourcing really important projects and all the benefits that they would provide to nations that have lower standards or perhaps no standards at all. That is worse for us, and it is worse for the environment.
I come from a State that has seen firsthand in living colors the harms that come with a broken permitting process. Yet you can't do much in Alaska without a Federal permit. That is our reality. And our experience in trying to obtain these permits is usually just pretty awful. There are probably better descriptives, but bottom line: It is pretty awful.
Just about every project that enters Federal permitting winds up being delayed and, again, costing more, and just about every project that eventually makes it through the process still winds up in court.
I will give a couple examples here. In the late 2000s, it took years to convince the Obama administration to let us build a bridge. It was a simple bridge. We were trying to allow for a petroleum project to advance within our National Petroleum Reserve. This is an area that is designated and leased for petroleum production. And this permit was not for the project itself; it was just for the bridge to help facilitate it. And it took years--years.
In Southeast Alaska, the permitting process for a gold mine down there started in the 1990s. It continued into the early 2010s. So you are talking now several decades. The agencies developed one set of environmental documents, and they were requested to do another set, and then they faced last-second legal challenges. Ultimately, it went all the way up to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Another example: Back in 1980, Congress passed a law guaranteeing that Alaskans would be allowed to construct a roughly 211-mile industrial road. This was in order to access a world-class mining district. Now, there are about 19 miles of this 211 miles of proposed road--19 miles that would have to go through Federal land, through BLM lands, and that has been the holdup here. The project entered Federal permitting back in 2016. After being approved in 2020, it was then voluntarily remanded by the last administration, and then it was reopened and then rejected, even though the law says--the law guarantees--that level of access.
So here we are a full decade later--in 2027--and you should legitimately ask the question: Well, did you build the road? And I can tell you: No, not even a mile. It is still in permitting.
We have also got a 15-mile stretch of highway--this is an important part of our State. It accesses our peninsula area. There is great fishing down there. We have been trying to make this road corridor safer now for years. We have been in the permitting process off and on for more than 40 years. I am looking at the young pages down here on the floor. Like twice your life we having been trying to get this 15-mile stretch worked through so we can avoid collisions and disasters on the road. We are only now getting through with it, so it has been a generational thing.
But permitting reform is critical for us in Alaska. It is critical throughout our country. But I look to what we have in my State. We have tens of billions of dollars' worth of projects that are underway. This is everything from oil and gas to clean coal, to renewables, to mining, to transportation. And we are a State that still lacks a lot of basic infrastructure, right, so we need these projects to help advance our State so that Alaskans can have some good jobs, have a higher standard of living, a sustainable economy. But when everything seems to hinge on Federal permits that are difficult, if not sometimes almost impossible, it really makes it hard.
So to be here at this juncture where we are talking about how we can finally advance BAAJA, again, I feel so gratified for those who have worked so hard. I want to commend the sponsors; Senators Lee and Senator Heinrich from the Energy and Natural Resources Committee; Senator Capito--Chairman Capito; Senator Whitehouse from EPW; all their committee folks. They have done great work, and they all deserve strong credit. But they really have worked together.
And they haven't done it by themselves. They brought us in. My colleague from Oklahoma who just recently arrived to the Senate this year has been all in, laser focused on permitting reform, permitting reform, permitting reform. So it is going to be so good to have the input that he has given to us. But it has been so many that have been engaged.
And as the Senator from North Dakota commented, this is not an easy subject to legislate on. It is hard to get this right at a substantive level, and it is even harder to navigate politically. We have been close to bipartisan success in the past. We had a really great effort with Senator Manchin and Senator Barrasso with their Energy Permitting Reform Act of 2024. They got so close but then fell short, which was disappointing.
But I think what you saw with the leadership of these four Senators was they didn't give up on that. They built on what they had inherited. They designed a bill that goes even further and, I think, really is the best one that we have seen on Federal permitting reform and why we need to get it enacted into law. This is our chance.
This is our chance to reform NEPA, to address the Endangered Species Act, the Clean Water Act--a lot of statutes that we are talking about here. But this is our chance to put firm deadlines on agency decisions, to give that clarity, to provide for clear limits on judicial review. It is our chance to put an end to many of the games and, quite honestly, some of the abuses that take place within a Federal permitting process.
There is a lot to like in BAAJA. And the Senators who worked to build this, I think they really took great pains to ensure that they were listening to other Members and listening to their priorities. I have several that they have incorporated as they relate to hydropower and geothermal. I have my FLOWS Act in there. But I am also very, very pleased that BAAJA includes bipartisan legislation that my vice chairman on the Indian Affairs Committee, Senator Schatz, and I introduced to reduce permitting barriers on Tribal lands and support Tribal economic development.
And I really want to thank the sponsors for working directly with me and my team on the Indian Affairs team. And I know, with my vice chair, that the bill, when it was introduced in September, it caught many a little bit--let's just say--off guard with a title that was contained in it that related to the National Historic Preservation Act.
And shortly after the text was released, I started to hear from Tribes, Tribal organizations. They were calling me from around Alaska and, really, from around the country, weighing in. They objected to the reforms that had been incorporated in the bill that related to the National Historic Preservation Act, NHPA.
But NHPA provides a really important process for the identification and the protection of sacred sites. These can include burial grounds, places of traditional religious and cultural importance to Tribes. But it also provides for this definition of what we call an undertaking. When a project involves a Federal action or approval, that is known as a Federal undertaking. And so we saw, we heard, from folks and looked very carefully at the text. And I agreed with them. I agreed. I think that NHPA needs to be modernized, but we also must--must--take Tribes' concerns very carefully and seriously to ensure that permitting reform does not come at the expense of meaningful consultation or the protection of properties of traditional religious and cultural importance. And so we all worked together. We worked over a long period of time to make what I think are substantial changes to address those concerns.
My team and I on the Indian Affairs Committee really get how important section 106 is to making sure that we get these projects right. In Alaska and across the country, Tribes and Federal Agencies have successfully used this process, again, to protect sacred sites, to minimize the impacts on culturally significant places, while still allowing projects to move forward.
So if you are working together, this can happen. You can still provide for the necessary and the very important protections while still allowing for that important project, whether it be a road or a transmission line or just whatever the project may be.
So this has been a really key effort in my State to address this. We have so many places of deep cultural and religious importance to Tribes that are located on lands that the Tribes no longer control. And so what section 106 does is it gives Tribes a voice when Federal projects may affect these sites by requiring agencies to consult with them and then to consider any potential impacts before--before--making the decisions.
And so, again, we heard from the Tribes and the Tribal organizations who weighed in. We asked the bill sponsors to work with us. And Senator Lee and his team were right there. They worked through some initial changes. But we needed to make some important changes to address the concerns that we had heard. And so let me just talk about some of the changes that we did secure that are either incorporated in the substitute or will be included as part of the managers' amendment when we are able to adopt that.
We removed a restrictive, unworkable definition for Tribal religious and cultural properties. This was really important, to be able to address that.
We have directed the Federal Government to help--not take over but to help--Tribal Historic Preservation Offices. These are the THPOs.
We improved opportunities for Tribes to participate in the identification of these historic properties, including the opportunity to review the findings, to raise substantive objections, and to receive a response--again, before the Federal decision is made. It doesn't help it if they don't get a response until after that decision is made.
We will increase the authorization for the Historic Preservation Fund to $300 million. This is in recognition of the fact that we need to support the Tribes and the Tribal Historic Preservation Offices, the THPOs, alongside the reforms to the review process. And so it was important to address that authorization.
We also addressed the most consequential question in this title, and that is: What qualifies as a Federal undertaking and, therefore, triggers this section 106 review process? So we secured changes to the definition of “undertaking” to preserve a pathway for section 106 review of projects when a Federal Agency exercises predominant control and responsibility over Federal financial assistance for a project's adverse effects on historic properties. So, again, this is particularly important in Alaska, where we have many sites of cultural and religious significance to Tribes that are located on State or private lands and then the Federal financial assistance supports infrastructure projects through the communities. So that was a significant one. We worked a long time, and hard, on that.
We also specifically preserved section 106 review for major Federally assisted transportation projects. These clearly have substantial footprints across our Nation.
So, again, the Senator from North Dakota used the word “balance,” and I started my comments off with acknowledging the balance in a bill and whether or not we have achieved perfection. Well, folks, we haven't achieved perfection. And I know that the changes that I have just outlined as they relate to the National Historic Preservation Act may not satisfy and resolve the concerns that have been raised by all of our Tribes, but the concerns that they raised--this is what led us to the substantive revisions of this text. And I truly want to thank those who weighed in with us--the Tribal leaders who sent the letters, who made the calls, who passed the resolutions, who came and met with me and met with my team.
Again, the NHPA title does not have every change that we wanted, but it is significantly better. And so I am hoping that Members on both sides of the aisle, in both Chambers, who have expressed similar concerns, those who have heard from their Tribes in their States and their regions, that they will look carefully at these changes that we have made and recognize what we have done.
So, again, is it a perfect bill? No. None of them are. We can't make that the standard for individual votes. We cannot keep holding out on permitting reform year after year in the hopes that maybe--just maybe-- somehow we are going to do it just a little bit better next time with just a little more time. This is it. This is it. This is our best option, not only for now but likely for years to come, for something that should have been done a long, long time ago.
So, in my view, BAAJA is absolutely worth supporting for affordability, for abundance, for jobs, for economic growth, for international competitiveness, and for so much more.
Again, I want to thank Chairman Lee, Chairman Capito, Ranking Member Heinrich, and Ranking Member Whitehouse, and all those who contributed so much to what I think is quite a considerable effort and undertaking and would urge Members support its final passage.
I yield the floor.