SURVIVOR JUSTICE TAX PREVENTION ACT
November 19, 2026 · Spoken on the Senate floor · 930 words
Mr. President, I rise today to express my deep concern that the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 poses significant threats to Tribal sovereignty as well as to one of our Nation's most precious wild places in my home State of Minnesota.
Read the full statement
Mr. President, I rise today to express my deep concern that the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 poses significant threats to Tribal sovereignty as well as to one of our Nation's most precious wild places in my home State of Minnesota.
On its face, this bill is aimed at increasing domestic energy production, making our electric grid more resilient, and lowering costs for American families--all goals I share. However, the devil is in the details, and I believe this bill does a lot of harm.
I have always said, and I still believe, that we need permitting reform. We need to update our outdated permitting process so we can lower energy costs by getting cleaner, cheaper power connected to the grid, but this bill is a bad deal that Democrats should not take. Language in this bill would not only make it much easier for Antofagasta to build its copper-sulfide mine in the watershed of our precious Boundary Waters, but also put at risk sacred historical sites of Tribal Nations and violate their sovereignty. We can reform permitting without violating Tribal sovereignty or sacrificing our water quality and precious public lands, in Minnesota and around the country.
A cornerstone responsibility of the Federal Government is to respect the sovereign rights of Tribal Nations and to adhere to our legal obligations defined in our treaties and trust agreements with Native Nations. This bill, unfortunately, was negotiated without consultation with Tribes, and as a result, it undermines our responsibilities for consultation and cooperation with Tribes. I have no doubt that all of you have heard about this directly from Tribal leaders over the last several weeks since the first text of this bill came out. I urge you to hear these concerns and remember that honoring Tribal sovereignty must be a constant in our work, not an option.
For Tribal Nations in Minnesota and across the country, this bill is an imminent threat to their cultural resources. For decades, the National Historic Preservation Act has protected Tribal cultural resources and other historic properties through a collaborative process with Tribes, States, and Federal Agencies. This process protects our Nation's historic resources, and in most cases, it moves quickly and efficiently. Tribal historic preservation officers estimate that the average time to complete their historic review process is 16 days, and 98 percent of projects are reviewed on time.
Now, I am not opposed to addressing impediments in this process where there are legitimate problems. But the changes made in this bill are unnecessarily broad and sweeping. They strike at the heart of the law by taking away Tribes' and States' power in the historic preservation review process. And once damage is done to historic sites, it can be impossible to undo. That is what we risk by passing this bill.
I am also gravely concerned that this bill will result in irreversible pollution from mining near the Boundary Waters Canoe Wilderness Area, or BWCA.
The BWCA is an incredible wilderness, home to some of the cleanest water you will find in the lower 48 States. It is a cherished place to families in Minnesota and beyond, including mine, and it is within the ceded territory of the Grand Portage, Bois Forte, and Fond du Lac Bands of Lake Superior Chippewa. I know many of my colleagues have spent time in the BWCA, either as children or adults.
This place is too special to risk greenlighting a foreign-owned company with a sketchy track record because, under the terms of this legislation, the Trump administration could greenlight illegal leases and permits to mine over the next 2 years, leaving virtually no recourse to stop the Twin Metals mine, which a foreign mining conglomerate hopes to build on the doorstep of the Boundary Waters.
I am not anti-mining; Minnesota is a mining State. But we cannot tolerate this mine in this place. The science and data have confirmed over many years that a copper sulfide mine on the boundaries of the Boundary Waters Canoe Wilderness Area poses an unacceptable environmental risk to the area.
The Trump administration and Republicans in this Congress have already revoked protections for this special place. This bill, should it become law, would loosen existing legal protections and create a pathway for the Trump administration to fast-track the approval and construction of this mine. Furthermore, language in this bill would make it nearly impossible for future administrations to take necessary actions to regulate or rescind approvals for the mine--even if they are made unlawfully by Trump administration--something we can and should fully expect.
For the Grand Portage, Bois Forte, and Fond du Lac Tribal Nations, this mine also poses threats to their treaty-protected rights to hunt, fish, and gather in their ceded territory, which covers the BWCA and surrounding areas.
Central to the Ojibwe tradition is wild rice, or manoomin, a sacred food found on fresh water in the Great Lakes Region. Manoomin is highly susceptible to sulfate pollution, the exact type of pollution we risk from this proposed mine. This bill undermines the Tribal Nations' ability to protect their treaty resources from mining, and that is unacceptable.
We need permitting reform, but I cannot support this bill in its current form, and I urge my colleagues supporting this bill to reconsider your position and vote no. Let us continue to negotiate and work for a commonsense bill that reforms permitting so we can build the clean energy projects we so desperately need, while also protecting the sovereign rights of Tribes and the precious places we all love so much.
Original page in the Congressional Record (172 Cong. Rec. S5797)