SURVIVOR JUSTICE TAX PREVENTION ACT
November 19, 2026 · Spoken on the Senate floor · 2,424 words
Mr. President, I rise today in support of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, of which I am one of the four co-authors.
Read the full statement
Mr. President, I rise today in support of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, of which I am one of the four co-authors.
On November 3, Americans sent a clear message to their elected officials: Life has gotten too expensive, and they want relief. Energy costs, groceries, insurance premiums--I repeatedly heard about all of these things as I met with voters around the country over the past year. And I am pleased to say that BAAJA will directly address voters' concern over rising energy costs by bringing down electricity prices. It will also, over time, mitigate the effects that climate change-driven extreme weather is having on property insurance premiums, grocery prices, healthcare costs, and more.
There are a lot of myths and misinformation out there about BAAJA. Unfortunately, some of this misinformation has been delivered right here on the Senate floor. So I want to set the record straight about BAAJA--what it does and what it doesn't do.
Let's start with the title that amends the National Environmental Policy Act, or NEPA. To hear BAAJA's critics, BAAJA would gut NEPA. It does no such thing.
First, BAAJA would focus NEPA environmental reviews on the sorts of large greenfield projects that could actually have major effects on the environment. We exempt from NEPA small administrative projects, projects where government involvement is minimal, and projects that retrofit or replace existing infrastructure. For example, in Rhode Island, the NEPA environmental review process was estimated to add thousands of dollars to the cost of each replacement bus shelter. That is ridiculous, and it is part of the reason why the American Public Transportation Association supports BAAJA.
In a similar streamlining vein, BAAJA would impose a unified review structure on Federal permitting under NEPA. BAAJA builds on existing timelines in NEPA and requires that all other Federal authorizations or permits be processed simultaneously and that decisions on these authorizations be rendered shortly following the NEPA environmental review process. It also imposes discipline on Agencies, with escalating penalties on Agencies that delay the process. Rather than wait 5 or 10 years to get a bridge or tunnel permitted, BAAJA will reduce those timelines to a little over 2 years. Research by Columbia University, as well as analysis by the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office, shows that BAAJA will reduce timelines for project approvals. And all Americans will benefit from that. Indeed, Columbia's research shows that transmission and clean energy projects will see their timelines accelerated the most, and this will benefit Americans in the form of cheaper electricity prices and less of the air pollution that harms our health and drives extreme weather and climate change.
The environment, too, will benefit. This past winter, a major sewage line ruptured under the Potomac River, resulting in the largest sewage spill in American history. Problems with the line had been signaled by the State of Maryland over 7 years ago, but replacement had been delayed by an environmental review process that dragged on across three administrations and was ongoing when the rupture occurred. This is unacceptable.
BAAJA does not, contrary to what its critics assert, gut public participation. BAAJA introduces a requirement that project sponsors submit a statement of stakeholder engagement as part of any complete application for an environmental review under NEPA. This will incentivize early stakeholder engagement and result in projects that are more respectful of community needs and interests. Similarly, BAAJA requires a public comment period for the sorts of large projects that go through the environmental impact statement process This is new and not currently required by law.
BAAJA also does not eliminate redressability. What it does is cabin the ability to stop a project's construction to instances where some other substantive law--the Endangered Species Act, the Clean Water Act, the Civil Rights Act are but three examples--or the Administrative Procedure Act is violated and where real harm is likely to occur. This makes sense, as NEPA is a purely procedural statute, and stopping a project just to force an Agency to fix paperwork errors makes no sense.
Let's move on to the title that amends the Clean Water Act. Here again, BAAJA's critics argue that it guts section 401 of the Clean Water Act. This is not true. BAAJA preserves section 401 (a) through (d) exactly as written. It adds a new subsection (g), which creates a special regime for interstate gas pipelines and interstate transmission lines where the 401 certification process would be triggered by direct discharges from a point source and a State's conditioning authority would be limited to such direct discharges. This makes sense. Gas pipelines and transmission lines present a lower risk profile for serious effects on water quality compared to mines, oil infrastructure, and dams, to name but a few other types of projects. And gas pipelines and transmission lines have both fallen victim to State politics on occasion. The changes in this subsection are designed to focus States on the Clean Water Act essential: ensuring water quality.
The next title of BAAJA amends the Endangered Species Act. It does two things. It codifies a definition of best available science very similar to the definition already used by the courts, and it creates a program for States to assume consultations under section 7. The same critics of BAAJA who defend State authority under section 401 of the Clean Water Act oppose this State assumption program. It has to be said: You can't both support and oppose federalism. Many of our leading environmental statues, including the Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act, provide substantial authority to the States to implement them. Importing a bit of cooperative federalism into the Endangered Species Act is not inconsistent with our canon of environmental law.
Indeed, States already assume NEPA reviews of Federal highway projects under a different State assumption program, and just like that program, the State assumption program in BAAJA requires that State authority be terminated if the State does not adequately implement the program.
Following the ESA title of BAAJA, there is a title on permit certainty. Unlike the other titles, this is new law, and so I will spend a bit of extra time discussing it.
Section 1401, and the rest of title IV's “Project Certainty” provisions, are intended to send a clear signal to Federal Agencies that Federal authorizations and permits are not political weapons. No administration, whether Democratic or Republican, should be making decisions about Federal permits for any project or class of projects based simply on their personal opinions about what kinds of projects they like politically and what projects they dislike politically. The job of Federal Agencies is to permit and regulate according to the procedures and standards in law, and project sponsors are entitled to expect that Agencies will not do so arbitrarily Sections 1401, 1402, and 1403 give that instruction to Agencies and provide substantial remedies intended to compensate and protect project sponsors if Agencies fail to act accordingly.
Section 1401 establishes a default principle that Agencies should not lightly interfere with existing Federal authorizations or permits for projects that already have all final approvals and then lays out the circumstances in which an Agency may revoke, suspend, or change approvals for these projects. Those enumerated reasons include subsections (A) when taken in response to a court order; (B) when the permit holder has breached the terms of the permit or materially violated applicable law; (C) when the permit was obtained through fraud or material misrepresentations; (D) when “necessary to prevent immediate, specific, urgent, substantial, and proximate harm or damage to life, property, human health, the environment, national security, or defense that is based on new information,” (E) when requested by the permit holder; and (F) when “taken pursuant to any applicable law or regulation.”
I would like to particularly highlight the exception in subsection (F). This exception is intentionally broad because section 1401 is not meant to interfere with the work of Agencies acting in good faith to give effect to the statutes, regulations, guidance, and other authority within their jurisdiction. There are dozens if not hundreds of statutes that authorize Agencies to act in ways that will impact existing permits or affect the construction or operation of a fully permitted project, and Agencies retain all those discretionary and nondiscretionary authorities. Agencies can still apply and enforce statutes and regulations, including new ones that come into effect after this law is enacted and after a permit is in effect.
If the EPA lawfully issues a new regulation that changes pollution standards under the Clean Air Act, it still can apply that regulation against the holders of existing permits. Similarly, nothing in this section interferes with OSHA's or PHMSA's ability to take any action authorized by any law or regulation. If an Agency discovers that a project is in violation of a law or that an authorization or determination was improperly granted in the first place, it can take lawful action against the project, even if doing so will have implications for the project's ability to operate at normal capacity. Nothing in section 1401 interferes with Agencies' ability to do things they are authorized to do by Federal laws like the Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, Safe Drinking Water Act, and Endangered Species Act or by lawful regulations issued under those laws. Section 1401 and its remedies come into play only when an Agency tries to interfere with a project's authorizations, construction, or operation in an arbitrary and capricious fashion that is not authorized by any applicable law or regulation.
The exception in subsection (D) further clarifies the line between reasonable and arbitrary agency interference with issued permits. Agencies can--and should--act swiftly to prevent danger to life, human health, the environment, property, or national security or defense, but they must identify risks that are specific, near-term, and substantial--not vague, remote, or hypothetical. An Agency can intervene to prevent an imminent risk of human exposure to or environmental release of chemicals like PFAS pollutants, which are known to cause cancer and harm to childhood development; it cannot revoke permits based on general, cryptic assertions that exposures or risks may someday arise.
In sum, the goal of section 1401 is to ensure that Agencies cannot use Federal permits to pick winners and losers in a manner divorced from law--and, importantly, to provide projects sponsors with significant remedies if Agencies try to do so. It will not interfere with the important regulatory and enforcement work that Agencies do under existing statutes.
Section 1401 also provides additional protection to five offshore wind projects that have already been the subject of Federal interference and have had that interference enjoined by a court order. This added protection is outlined in the “Special Rule” subsection and requires the Federal Government to obtain a court order before it takes any further action against any of these projects.
Offshore wind projects are not the only projects that have found themselves caught up in an overly politicized permitting process. Wind projects have been stalled at DOD, and wind and solar projects have been stalled at Interior. I appreciate the White House's cooperation in reaching a political agreement during our permitting reform negotiations to advance land-based wind projects that had been stalled at DOD for more than a year. The mitigation agreements DOD has now executed and the other wind projects it has cleared were all specifically part of that political agreement. While I welcome these actions, they reflect the commitments made by the White House, rather than a broader resumption of DOD's normal review process. We have not seen comparable progress outside the agreement.
Importantly, DOD is executing mitigation agreements negotiated before the freeze began, without imposing additional national security mitigation requirements That raises serious questions about why these projects were stalled in the first place, particularly given DOD's shifting national security explanations for the delays. Approximately 300 other projects remain stalled. DOD must resume its normal review process for all projects, not just those covered by the political agreement. Developers should not need a political agreement to receive the reviews and decisions required by law.
If DOD does not resume processing mitigation agreements for wind projects and Interior does not resume the permitting of renewable projects, they will run afoul of section 1402 of BAAJA, which imposes large penalties on the Federal Government when it engages in a pattern of disparate treatment in the permitting process, either through delaying decisions beyond the applicable deadline or denying authorizations. Such delays or denials have to have substantially increased across the specific class of project, as has been the case for wind and solar projects over the last 2 years. Section 1402 allows for a 6-month grace period before a cause of action may be brought under it for delayed or denied non-NEPA authorizations and a 9-month grace period for NEPA authorizations, in order to allow time for Federal Agencies to get back to permitting these projects. The administration has assured us that it understands that it must process applications or face massive financial penalties under section 1402. We will be watching vigilantly to make sure that they keep their word or face the consequences this section imposes.
Finally, section 1403 creates a new 1-year unified timeline for all non-NEPA Federal authorizations. This is important, as there are a plethora of Federal authorizations, and any one of them could be weaponized by an administration hostile to a particular type of project. Creating a timeline offers them protection under section 1402 and has the further benefit of injecting discipline into often slow, unaccountable Agencies and inter-agency process.
I will not spend as much time discussing the titles of this bill in the Energy Committee's jurisdiction, as they do not relate to the committee on which I am the ranking member. Suffice it to say, they are excellent. They will simplify and streamline the siting and permitting of long-distance transmission lines, help unclog the interconnection queue, and force data centers to pay for the costs they impose on the grid. Taken together, these provisions are modeled to save ratepayers more than $10 billion per year--an enormous down payment on affordability--and will reduce power sector emissions on a gigaton scale, up to 20 percent.
BAAJA marks a major step in facilitating our Nation's clean energy renaissance, a renaissance that will lower costs, create well-paying jobs, reduce pollution, and fight climate change. It will also create rigor in an otherwise too-often politicized and unaccountable permitting process, resulting in faster timelines for infrastructure, housing, and so much more. Let's pass this bill.
Original page in the Congressional Record (172 Cong. Rec. S5797)